![](https://img.youtube.com/vi/NJXCw4nUgkk/hqdefault.jpg)
Athlético PR 1-1 Fortaleza - September 14, 2024 / Série A 2024
. All the information you will find here have been collected manually from the most official sources. However, if you found any mistake or any missing information, please contact us.Série A 2024 - Round 26
AP
![photo Moises](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_406/406031.webp)
![photo Agustín Canobbio](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_301/301681.webp)
![photo Benjamin Kuscevic](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_234/234232.webp)
AP
![photo Pablo Felipe](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_147/147443.webp)
![photo Gonzalo Mastriani](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_143/143256.webp)
![photo Breno Lopes](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_294/294500.webp)
![photo Moises](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_406/406031.webp)
![photo João Cruz](/images/base/default_user.png)
![photo Tinga](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_261/261520.webp)
![photo Eros Mancuso](/images/photos/resampled/players/76/a_447/447384.webp)
![photo Tomas Pochettino](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_280/280249.webp)
![photo Kervin Andrade](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_447/447390.webp)
![photo Bruno Praxedes](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_407/407718.webp)
![photo Tomas Cuello](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_319/319692.webp)
![photo Julimar](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_383/383524.webp)
![photo Bruno Zapelli](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_463/463521.webp)
![photo Juan Martín Lucero](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_124/124585.webp)
![photo Renato Kayzer](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_274/274894.webp)
![photo Imanol Machuca](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_432/432595.webp)
![photo Marinho](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_68/68771.webp)
![photo Lucas Di Yorio](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_296/296446.webp)
![photo João Cruz](/images/base/default_user.png)
![photo João Ricardo](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_198/198560.webp)
![photo Agustín Canobbio](/images/photos/resampled/players/2024/76/a_301/301681.webp)
FOR
FOR
Team line-ups
Athlético PR
First 11 |
Age | Match num | Note | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
41 | G |
Mycael Pontes | 20 | 6 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
4 | D |
Kaique Rocha | 23 | 65 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
15 | D |
Mateo Gamarra | 23 | 30 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
37 | D |
Lucas Esquivel | 22 | 62 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
57 | M |
João Cruz | 8561 | 18 | 12 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
28 | M |
Tomas Cuello | 71 | 24 | 148 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
14 | M |
Agustín Canobbio | 2891 | 25 | 133 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
3 | M |
Gabriel | 32 | 19 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
26 | D |
Erick | 26 | 269 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
10 | M |
Bruno Zapelli | 71 | 22 | 69 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
9 | F |
Gonzalo Mastriani | 58 | 31 | 40 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player |
Average age
24.2 years
Average number of matches played for the team
78
Fortaleza
First 11 |
Age | Match num | Note | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | G |
João Ricardo | 85 | 36 | 106 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
13 | D |
Benjamin Kuscevic | 39 | 28 | 32 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
25 | D |
Tomás Cardona | 28 | 31 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
33 | D |
Eros Mancuso | 68 | 25 | 2 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
36 | D |
Felipe Jonatan | 26 | 21 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
17 | M |
Zé Welison | 29 | 137 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
28 | M |
Pedro Augusto | 27 | 60 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | ||
79 | F |
Renato Kayzer | 78 | 28 | 49 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
21 | M |
Moises | 1460 | 28 | 129 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
77 | M |
Kervin Andrade | 68 | 19 | 29 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
11 | M |
Marinho | 78 | 34 | 61 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player |
Average age
28 years
Average number of matches played for the team
60
Substitutes |
Age | Match num | Note | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
24 | G |
Leo Linck | 23 | ||||
44 | D |
Thiago Heleno | 35 | ||||
23 | D |
Felipinho | 22 | ||||
43 | D |
Marcos Victor | 22 | ||||
29 | D |
Leonardo Godoy | 29 | ||||
22 | D |
Madson | 32 | ||||
61 | D |
Leonardo Derik | 19 | ||||
8 | M |
Bruno Praxedes | 71 | 22 | 2 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
11 | M |
Nikão | 32 | ||||
7 | F |
Lucas Di Yorio | 85 | 27 | 30 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
20 | F |
Julimar | 71 | 23 | 71 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
92 | F |
Pablo Felipe | 58 | 32 | 307 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player |
Substitutes |
Age | Match num | Note | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
30 | G |
Mauricio Kozlinski | 33 | ||||
14 | D |
Jhonatan Silva | 25 | ||||
4 | D |
Titi | 36 | ||||
2 | D |
Tinga | 68 | 31 | 356 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
88 | M |
Lucas Sasha | 34 | ||||
7 | M |
Tomas Pochettino | 68 | 28 | 117 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
35 | M |
Hércules | 23 | ||||
37 | M |
Kauan | 19 | ||||
39 | M |
Imanol Machuca | 78 | 24 | 64 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
10 | M |
Calebe | 24 | ||||
26 | F |
Breno Lopes | 60 | 28 | 25 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player | |
9 | F |
Juan Martín Lucero | 78 | 32 | 113 | You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player |
Changes in the starting players regarding the previous match
Mateo Gamarra
IN
Thiago Heleno
OUT
João Cruz
IN
Christian
OUT
Changes in the starting players regarding the previous match
Tomás Cardona
IN
Titi
OUT
Zé Welison
IN
Lucas Sasha
OUT
Renato Kayzer
IN
Juan Martín Lucero
OUT
Benjamin Kuscevic
IN
Emanuel Britez
OUT
Marinho
IN
Yago Pikachu
OUT
Eros Mancuso
IN
Tinga
OUT
Kervin Andrade
IN
Tomas Pochettino
OUT
Moises
IN
Breno Lopes
OUT
Pedro Augusto
IN
Hércules
OUT
Manager
Age
Match num
33
17
Success rate in this team:
47 %
Success rate since the beginning of his career:
38 %
Varini vs Fortaleza
0 victory
1 draw
0 loss
Varini vs Vojvoda
0 victory
1 draw
0 loss
Manager
Age
Match num
49
259
Success rate in this team:
49 %
Success rate since the beginning of his career:
47 %
Vojvoda vs Athlético PR
3 victories
4 draws
1 loss
Vojvoda vs Varini
0 victory
1 draw
0 loss
Referee
Davi de Oliveira Lacerda
0 victory |
1 draw |
2 losses |
Athlético PR3 matches | General total | Fortaleza5 matches | 2 victories |
2 draws |
1 loss |
0 victory |
1 draw |
2 losses |
Athlético PR3 matches | Season total | Fortaleza5 matches | 2 victories |
2 draws |
1 loss |
Latest figure on September 29, 2024 | Latest figure on October 04, 2024 |
Assistant Referee
Felipe Alan Costa de Oliveira
0 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Athlético PR1 match | General total | Fortaleza1 match | 0 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
0 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Athlético PR1 match | Season total | Fortaleza1 match | 0 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Latest figure on September 14, 2024 | Latest figure on September 14, 2024 |
Assistant Referee
Fernanda Nandrea Gomes Antunes
0 victory |
2 draws |
1 loss |
Athlético PR3 matches | General total | Fortaleza2 matches | 1 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
0 victory |
2 draws |
1 loss |
Athlético PR3 matches | Season total | Fortaleza2 matches | 1 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Latest figure on September 14, 2024 | Latest figure on September 29, 2024 |
4th official
Luiz Paulo De Moura Pinheiro
0 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Athlético PR1 match | General total | Fortaleza2 matches | 1 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
0 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Athlético PR1 match | Season total | Fortaleza2 matches | 1 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Latest figure on September 14, 2024 | Latest figure on September 14, 2024 |
Assistant Referee VAR
Rodrigo D'Alonso Ferreira
1 victory |
1 draw |
2 losses |
Athlético PR4 matches | General total | Fortaleza2 matches | 0 victory |
2 draws |
0 loss |
1 victory |
1 draw |
2 losses |
Athlético PR4 matches | Season total | Fortaleza2 matches | 0 victory |
2 draws |
0 loss |
Latest figure on December 08, 2024 | Latest figure on September 14, 2024 |
Assistant VAR Referee
Vitor Carmona Metestaine
0 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Athlético PR1 match | General total | Fortaleza3 matches | 1 victory |
1 draw |
1 loss |
0 victory |
1 draw |
0 loss |
Athlético PR1 match | Season total | Fortaleza3 matches | 1 victory |
1 draw |
1 loss |
Latest figure on September 14, 2024 | Latest figure on September 14, 2024 |
Videos
Key figures
![icon stats](/images/base/stats.png)
End of streak for Athlético PR after 5 consecutive losses at home in Série A (since 03/07/2024). It's a record streak. The previous one was back on the 30/10/2021 (3 matches)
![icon stats](/images/base/record.png)
Athlético PR keeps its 3 1-1 vs Fortaleza at home running (since 05/10/2022). It's a record streak. The first of history
![icon stats](/images/base/stats.png)
End of streak for Fortaleza after 7 consecutive matches without a draw in Série A (since 27/07/2024). It was the best streak for the club since 10/06/2023-20/09/2023 (15 matches).
General ranking
10 | Atlético Mineiro | 33 pts | 23 rd | |
11 | Red Bull Bragantino | 30 pts | 24 rd | |
12 | Athlético Paranaense | 30 pts | 24 rd | |
13 | Juventude | 29 pts | 25 rd | |
14 | Criciúma | 28 pts | 24 rd |
General ranking
1 | Botafogo | 53 pts | 26 rd | |
2 | Fortaleza | 49 pts | 26 rd | |
3 | Palmeiras | 47 pts | 25 rd | |
4 | Flamengo | 44 pts | 24 rd | |
5 | Cruzeiro | 41 pts | 25 rd |
Pre-match
Current form
Home | VAthlético Paranaense 2-0 Red Bull Bragantino31/07/2024 | LAthlético Paranaense 0-2 Grêmio04/08/2024 | VAthlético Paranaense 2-1 Belgrano de Córdoba15/08/2024 | LAthlético Paranaense 1-2 Juventude18/08/2024 | LAthlético Paranaense 0-2 Palmeiras01/09/2024 | VAthlético Paranaense 2-1 Vasco da Gama11/09/2024 |
Overall | LAthlético Paranaense 1-2 Juventude18/08/2024 | VBelgrano de Córdoba 0-2 Athlético Paranaense22/08/2024 | LVasco da Gama 2-1 Athlético Paranaense26/08/2024 | LVasco da Gama 2-1 Athlético Paranaense29/08/2024 | LAthlético Paranaense 0-2 Palmeiras01/09/2024 | VAthlético Paranaense 2-1 Vasco da Gama11/09/2024 |
Current form
Away | DCriciúma 1-1 Fortaleza24/07/2024 | VCruzeiro 1-2 Fortaleza05/08/2024 | DRosario Central 1-1 Fortaleza14/08/2024 | VRed Bull Bragantino 1-2 Fortaleza17/08/2024 | LBotafogo 2-0 Fortaleza31/08/2024 | LInternacional 2-1 Fortaleza11/09/2024 |
Overall | DRosario Central 1-1 Fortaleza14/08/2024 | VRed Bull Bragantino 1-2 Fortaleza17/08/2024 | VFortaleza 3-1 Rosario Central21/08/2024 | VFortaleza 1-0 Corinthians25/08/2024 | LBotafogo 2-0 Fortaleza31/08/2024 | LInternacional 2-1 Fortaleza11/09/2024 |
Running streaks
Home | Total | |
---|---|---|
Winning streak | 1 | 1 |
Unbeaten streak | 1 | 1 |
Drawless streak | 10 | 7 |
Scoring streak | 1 | 1 |
Conceding streak | 5 | 4 |
Running streaks
Away | Total | |
---|---|---|
Loosing streak | 2 | 2 |
Winless streak | 2 | 2 |
Drawless streak | 3 | 5 |
Scoring streak | 1 | 1 |
Conceding streak | 15 | 2 |
Statistical comparison of the season
Rankings
12 |
General ranking (Competition total) |
2 |
17 |
General ranking (Home / Away) |
7 |
115 |
FBDB index ranking (Worldwide) |
52 |
13 |
FBDB index ranking (National) |
1 |
Ranking evolution during the season
Results
23 |
Number of games (Competition total) |
25 |
11 |
Number of games (Home / Away) |
12 |
8 |
Victories (Competition total) |
14 |
4 |
Victories (Home / Away) |
4 |
5 |
Draws (Competition total) |
6 |
2 |
Draws (Home / Away) |
3 |
10 |
Losses (Competition total) |
5 |
5 |
Losses (Home / Away) |
5 |
Goals
26 |
Goals scored (Competition total) |
31 |
14 |
Goals scored (Home / Away) |
11 |
28 |
Goals conceded (Competition total) |
24 |
14 |
Goals conceded (Home / Away) |
18 |
1.13 |
Goals scored per match average (Competition total) |
1.24 |
1.27 |
Goals scored per match average (Home / Away) |
0.92 |
1.22 |
Conceced goals per match average (Competition total) |
0.96 |
1.27 |
Conceced goals per match average (Home / Away) |
1.5 |
Betting aid
9 |
Number of matches with more than 2,5 goals (Competition total) |
10 |
5 |
Number of matches with more than 2,5 goals (Home / Away) |
6 |
5 |
Clean sheets (Competition total) |
8 |
3 |
Clean sheets (Home / Away) |
1 |
6 |
Matches without scoring (Competition total) |
5 |
2 |
Matches without scoring (Home / Away) |
5 |
12 |
The 2 teams score (Competition total) |
13 |
6 |
The 2 teams score (Home / Away) |
7 |
1-0 |
Most frequent score (Home / Away) |
2-1 |
Bookings
59 |
Yellow cards (Competition total) |
68 |
20 |
Yellow cards (Home / Away) |
34 |
3 |
Red cards (Competition total) |
6 |
2 |
Red cards (Home / Away) |
4 |
Key players
![]() | Gonzalo Mastriani | 4 goals | Team's best scorer (Competition total) | 8 goals | Juan Martín Lucero | ![]() |
![]() | Gonzalo Mastriani | 3 goals | Team's best scorer (Home / Away) | 3 goals | Juan Martín Lucero | ![]() |
![]() | Fernandinho | 1 penalty | Team's penalty best scorer (Competition total) | 2 penalties | Juan Martín Lucero | ![]() |
![]() | Fernandinho | 1 penalty | Team's penalty best scorer (Home / Away) | - | ||
![]() | Fernandinho | 3 assists | Player with most assists (Competition total) | 5 assists | Tomas Pochettino | ![]() |
![]() | Fernandinho | 2 assists | Player with most assists (Home / Away) | 3 assists | Tomas Pochettino | ![]() |
![]() | Nikão | 1 goal, 1 assist during the last 3 matches | The fittest player | 1 goal during the last match | Titi | ![]() |
Historical head to head
Home
14 gf
6 ga
Away
12 gf
14 ga
Total
26 gf
20 ga
Historical head to head
Home
14 gf
12 ga
Away
6 gf
14 ga
Total
20 gf
26 ga
Largest victory
Overall | 4 - 1 |
September 26, 2019 |
Home | 4 - 1 |
September 26, 2019 |
Largest victory
Overall | 3 - 0 |
October 23, 2021 |
Away | No success yet |
Latest head to head
June 02, 2024 - Série A 2024
November 08, 2023 - Série A 2023
July 09, 2023 - Série A 2023
October 05, 2022 - Série A 2022
June 12, 2022 - Série A 2022
Best historical scorers against Fortaleza
![]() |
Léo Cittadini | 2 goals | 2019 - 2020 |
![]() |
Marco Ruben | 2 goals | 2019 - 2019 |
![]() |
Daniel Horst | 2 goals | 2003 - 2003 |
![]() |
Dagoberto | 1 goal | 2005 - 2005 |
![]() |
Matheus Babi | 1 goal | 2021 - 2021 |
![]() |
Luciano Santos | 1 goal | 2003 - 2003 |
Best historical scorers against Athlético PR
![]() |
Yago Pikachu | 2 goals | 2021 - 2023 |
![]() |
Wellington Paulista | 2 goals | 2019 - 2019 |
![]() |
Lúcio Bala | 2 goals | 2006 - 2006 |
![]() |
Fernandão | 1 goal | 2003 - 2003 |
![]() |
Robson Fernandes | 1 goal | 2021 - 2021 |
![]() |
Thiago Galhardo | 1 goal | 2022 - 2022 |
Players with most games played vs Fortaleza
![]() |
Christian | 8 matches | 2020 - 2024 |
![]() |
Nikão | 8 matches | 2019 - 2024 |
![]() |
Erick | 7 matches | 2019 - 2024 |
![]() |
Léo Cittadini | 7 matches | 2019 - 2023 |
![]() |
Bento | 6 matches | 2021 - 2024 |
![]() |
Khellven | 6 matches | 2020 - 2023 |
Players with most games played vs Athlético PR
![]() |
Tinga | 8 matches | 2019 - 2024 |
![]() |
Romarinho | 8 matches | 2019 - 2022 |
![]() |
Titi | 6 matches | 2021 - 2023 |
![]() |
Marlon Adriano | 6 matches | 2019 - 2020 |
![]() |
Yago Pikachu | 5 matches | 2021 - 2023 |
![]() |
Wellington Paulista | 5 matches | 2019 - 2021 |
They played in both sides
259 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
4 matches
136 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
6 matches
113 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
22 matches
107 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
53 matches
82 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
48 matches
78 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
24 matches
They played in both sides
6 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
142 matches
58 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
73 matches
19 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
68 matches
5 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
57 matches
25 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
54 matches
107 matches
![Athlético Paranaense logo Athlético Paranaense](/images/photos/clubs/a_1/1909.png)
![Fortaleza logo Fortaleza](/images/photos/clubs/a_3/3158.png)
53 matches
Competition info
The other matches
September 14, 2024
September 15, 2024
September 17, 2024
Post-match general ranking
pts | m | v | d | l | GF | GA | diff | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1
| ![]() | Botafogo | 53 | 26 | 16 | 5 | 5 | 45 | 25 | +20 |
2
| ![]() | Fortaleza | 49 | 26 | 14 | 7 | 5 | 32 | 25 | +7 |
3
| ![]() | Palmeiras | 47 | 25 | 14 | 5 | 6 | 38 | 19 | +19 |
4
| ![]() | Flamengo | 44 | 24 | 13 | 5 | 6 | 39 | 28 | +11 |
5
| ![]() | Cruzeiro | 41 | 25 | 12 | 5 | 8 | 34 | 26 | +8 |
6
| ![]() | São Paulo | 41 | 25 | 12 | 5 | 8 | 33 | 26 | +7 |
7
| ![]() | Bahia | 39 | 25 | 11 | 6 | 8 | 34 | 27 | +7 |
8
| ![]() | Internacional | 35 | 23 | 9 | 8 | 6 | 24 | 20 | +4 |
9
| ![]() | Vasco da Gama | 34 | 24 | 10 | 4 | 10 | 29 | 34 | -5 |
10
| ![]() | Atlético Mineiro | 33 | 23 | 8 | 9 | 6 | 32 | 33 | -1 |
11
| ![]() | Red Bull Bragantino | 30 | 24 | 8 | 6 | 10 | 29 | 30 | -1 |
12
| ![]() | Athlético Paranaense | 30 | 24 | 8 | 6 | 10 | 27 | 29 | -2 |
13
| ![]() | Juventude | 29 | 25 | 7 | 8 | 10 | 29 | 35 | -6 |
14
| ![]() | Criciúma | 28 | 24 | 7 | 7 | 10 | 32 | 35 | -3 |
15
| ![]() | Grêmio | 27 | 23 | 8 | 3 | 12 | 23 | 28 | -5 |
16
| ![]() | Fluminense | 27 | 24 | 7 | 6 | 11 | 20 | 26 | -6 |
+117
| ![]() | Vitória | 25 | 26 | 7 | 4 | 15 | 28 | 39 | -11 |
-118
| ![]() | Corinthians | 25 | 26 | 5 | 10 | 11 | 23 | 33 | -10 |
19
| ![]() | Cuiabá | 22 | 24 | 5 | 7 | 12 | 23 | 35 | -12 |
20
| ![]() | Atlético Goianiense | 18 | 26 | 4 | 6 | 16 | 21 | 42 | -21 |
Comments