This page offers all the statistics of the match and the pre-match of

Columbus Crew 4-1 New York City FC - October 31, 2017 / MLS 2017

. All the information you will find here have been collected manually from the most official sources. However, if you found any mistake or any missing information, please contact us.

MLS 2017 - 1/2 finales de conférence

Mapfre Stadium - Columbus - United States

October 31, 2017 - 20:00

14 416

Columbus Crew

4 - 1

New York City FC

Ola Kamara

Assist by Federico Higuaín Artur

58'

Assist by Ola KamaraJustin Meram

69'

Assist by Justin MeramHarrison Afful

90+3'

78'

David Villa

logo Columbus Crew CC

6' - Goal Ola Kamara6

logo Columbus Crew CC

52' - Red card Alexander Callens

56' - Substitution Rodney Wallaceis substituted by Ronald Matarrita

58' - Goal Artur58

64' - Yellow card Ronald Matarrita

69' - Goal Justin Meram69

74' - Substitution Ethan Whiteis substituted by Andraz Struna

75' - Substitution Pedro Santosis substituted by Kekuta Manneh75

78' - Goal David Villa

79' - Substitution Jack Harrisonis substituted by Sean Okoli

88' - Substitution Federico Higuaínis substituted by Lalas Abubakar88

91' - Substitution Arturis substituted by Mohamed Abu91

93' - Goal Harrison Afful93

logo New York City FC NYC

Team line-ups Key figures Pre-match Competition info

Columbus Crew

4 - 1

New York City FC

Columbus Crew New York City FC

Team line-ups

Columbus Crew

forward

offensive midfielder

midfielder

defensive midfielder

defender

sweeper

goalkeeper

11Kamara6

Ola Kamara

Norway

B.date15/10/1989

Age28 years

H1m83

positionStriker

9Meram69

Justin Meram

Iraq

B.date04/12/1988

Age28 years

H1m85

positionLeft Winger

10Higuaín88

Federico Higuaín

Argentina

B.date25/10/1984

Age33 years

H1m73

positionPlaymaker

32Santos75

Pedro Santos

Portugal

B.date22/04/1988

Age29 years

H1m73

positionWinger

7Artur5890+1

Artur

Brazil

B.date11/03/1996

Age21 years

H1m81

positionDefensive Midfielder

20Trapp

Will Trapp

United States

B.date15/01/1993

Age24 years

H1m73

positionDefensive Midfielder

16Jiménez

Hector Jiménez

United States

B.date03/11/1988

Age28 years

H1m75

positionRight full-back

3Williams

Josh Williams

United States

B.date18/04/1988

Age29 years

H1m88

positionCentral defender

4Mensah

Jonathan Mensah

Ghana

B.date13/07/1990

Age27 years

H1m88

positionCentral defender

25Afful93

Harrison Afful

Ghana

B.date24/07/1986

Age31 years

H1m70

positionRight full-back

23Steffen

Zack Steffen

United States

B.date02/06/1995

Age22 years

H1m91

positionGoalkeeper

First 11				Age	Match num	Note
23	G	Zack Steffen		22	36	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
3	D	Josh Williams		29	101	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
4	D	Jonathan Mensah		27	28	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
25	D	Harrison Afful	93	31	70	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
16	D	Hector Jiménez		28	101	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
7	M	Artur	5890+1	21	27	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
20	M	Will Trapp		24	141	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
10	M	Federico Higuaín	88	33	160	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
32	M	Pedro Santos	75	29	11	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
9	M	Justin Meram	69	28	210	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
11	F	Ola Kamara	6	28	62	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player

Average age

27.3 years

Average number of matches played for the team

New York City FC

forward

offensive midfielder

midfielder

defensive midfielder

defender

sweeper

goalkeeper

7Villa78

David Villa

Spain

B.date03/12/1981

Age35 years

H1m75

positionStriker

23Wallace56

Rodney Wallace

Costa Rica

B.date17/06/1988

Age29 years

H1m80

positionLeft Winger

11Harrison79

Jack Harrison

England

B.date20/11/1996

Age20 years

H1m75

positionLeft Offensive Midfielder

10Morález

Maximiliano Morález

Argentina

B.date27/02/1987

Age30 years

H1m60

positionPlaymaker

30Herrera

Yangel Herrera

Venezuela

B.date07/01/1998

Age19 years

H1m84

positionDefensive Midfielder

8Ring

Alexander Ring

Finland

B.date09/04/1991

Age26 years

H1m73

positionCentre Midfield

2Sweat

Ben Sweat

United States

B.date04/09/1991

Age26 years

H1m89

positionLeft full-back

6Callens52

Alexander Callens

Peru

B.date04/05/1992

Age25 years

H1m85

positionLeft central defender

13Brillant

Frédéric Brillant

France

B.date26/05/1985

Age32 years

H1m90

positionRight central defender

3White74

Ethan White

United States

B.date01/01/1991

Age26 years

H1m83

positionCentral defender

1Johnson

Sean Johnson

United States

B.date31/05/1989

Age28 years

H1m93

positionGoalkeeper

First 11				Age	Match num	Note
1	G	Sean Johnson		28	34	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
3	D	Ethan White	74	26	37	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
6	D	Alexander Callens	52	25	36	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
13	D	Frédéric Brillant		32	58	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
2	D	Ben Sweat		26	28	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
30	M	Yangel Herrera		19	19	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
8	M	Alexander Ring		26	31	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
11	M	Jack Harrison	79	20	60	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
10	M	Maximiliano Morález		30	31	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
23	M	Rodney Wallace	56	29	27	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
7	F	David Villa	78	35	98	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player

Average age

26.9 years

Average number of matches played for the team

Substitutes				Age	Match num	Note
41	G	Brad Stuver		26
17	D	Lalas Abubakar	88	22	8	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
14	D	Waylon Francis		27
8	M	Mohamed Abu	90+1	25	21	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
28	M	Niko Hansen		23
19	F	Kekuta Manneh	75	22	21	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
12	F	Adam Jahn		26

Substitutes				Age	Match num	Note
25	G	Eirik Johansen		25
22	D	Ronald Matarrita	5664	23	40	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
32	D	Andraz Struna	74	28	6	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player
5	M	Mikey Lopez		24
15	M	Tommy McNamara		26
17	M	Jonathan Lewis		20
9	F	Sean Okoli	79	24	18	You have to sign in to cast your vote for this player

Changes in the starting players regarding the previous match

No changes regarding the previous match for the starting players

Changes in the starting players regarding the previous match

No changes regarding the previous match for the starting players

Manager

Age

Match num

Gregg Berhalter

152

Success rate in this team:

39 %

Success rate since the beginning of his career:

39 %

Berhalter vs New York City FC

3 victories

3 draws

2 losses

Latest figure on October 31, 2017

Berhalter vs Vieira

2 victories

2 draws

2 losses

Latest figure on October 31, 2017

Manager

Age

Match num

Patrick Vieira

Success rate in this team:

42 %

Success rate since the beginning of his career:

46 %

Vieira vs Columbus Crew

2 victories

2 draws

2 losses

Latest figure on October 31, 2017

Vieira vs Berhalter

2 victories

2 draws

2 losses

Latest figure on October 31, 2017

Referee

Alan Kelly

5 victories	2 draws	9 losses	Columbus Crew16 matches	General total	New York City FC17 matches	7 victories	4 draws	6 losses
1 victory	0 draw	3 losses	Columbus Crew4 matches	Season total	New York City FC3 matches	2 victories	0 draw	1 loss
Latest figure on October 23, 2021					Latest figure on July 30, 2021

4th official

Ismail Elfath

3 victories	0 draw	0 loss	Columbus Crew3 matches	General total	New York City FC5 matches	2 victories	1 draw	2 losses
1 victory	0 draw	0 loss	Columbus Crew1 match	Season total	New York City FC2 matches	1 victory	0 draw	1 loss
Latest figure on July 16, 2020					Latest figure on September 14, 2021

Video referee

Hilario Grajeda

8 victories	2 draws	3 losses	Columbus Crew13 matches	General total	New York City FC3 matches	0 victory	1 draw	2 losses
3 victories	0 draw	0 loss	Columbus Crew3 matches	Season total	New York City FC1 match	0 victory	0 draw	1 loss
Latest figure on April 18, 2021					Latest figure on March 01, 2020

Videos

November 04, 2017

Comments

Key figures

David Villa scored 8 goals vs Columbus Crew in Major League Soccer

New York City FC keeps its 4 matches with at least one goal conceded running (since 30/09/2017).

End of streak for Columbus Crew after 4 consecutive matches without a win vs New York City FC (since 13/08/2016). It's a record streak. The first of history

Read the next 16 key stats

Pre-match

Current form

Home

VColumbus Crew 3-1 Chicago Fire12/08/2017

VColumbus Crew 2-0 Los Angeles Galaxy23/08/2017

VColumbus Crew 2-1 FC Dallas26/08/2017

DColumbus Crew 1-1 Sporting Kansas City10/09/2017

VColumbus Crew 3-2 New York Red Bulls23/09/2017

VColumbus Crew 2-0 D.C. United30/09/2017

Overall

DVancouver Whitecaps 2-2 Columbus Crew16/09/2017

VColumbus Crew 3-2 New York Red Bulls23/09/2017

VColumbus Crew 2-0 D.C. United30/09/2017

VOrlando City 0-1 Columbus Crew15/10/2017

DNew York City FC 2-2 Columbus Crew22/10/2017

DAtlanta United 0-0 Columbus Crew26/10/2017

Current form

Away

VLos Angeles Galaxy 0-2 New York City FC12/08/2017

DNew York Red Bulls 1-1 New York City FC25/08/2017

DColorado Rapids 1-1 New York City FC16/09/2017

VCF Montréal 0-1 New York City FC27/09/2017

DChicago Fire 1-1 New York City FC30/09/2017

LNew England Revolution 2-1 New York City FC15/10/2017

Overall

DColorado Rapids 1-1 New York City FC16/09/2017

DNew York City FC 1-1 Houston Dynamo23/09/2017

VCF Montréal 0-1 New York City FC27/09/2017

DChicago Fire 1-1 New York City FC30/09/2017

LNew England Revolution 2-1 New York City FC15/10/2017

DNew York City FC 2-2 Columbus Crew22/10/2017

Running streaks

	Home	Total
Winning streak	2	0
Drawing streak	0	2
Unbeaten streak	7	11
Winless streak	0	2
Drawless streak	2	0
Scoring streak	7	0
Goalless streak	0	1
Invincibility streak	1	1

Running streaks

	Away	Total
Drawing streak	0	1
Loosing streak	1	0
Unbeaten streak	0	1
Winless streak	2	3
Drawless streak	1	0
Scoring streak	6	6
Conceding streak	2	3

Statistical comparison of the season

Rankings

600	FBDB index ranking (Worldwide)	614
3	FBDB index ranking (National)	5

Results

35	Number of games (Competition total)	34
17	Number of games (Home / Away)	17
16	Victories (Competition total)	16
12	Victories (Home / Away)	6
7	Draws (Competition total)	9
2	Draws (Home / Away)	4
12	Losses (Competition total)	9
3	Losses (Home / Away)	7

Goals

53	Goals scored (Competition total)	56
34	Goals scored (Home / Away)	23
49	Goals conceded (Competition total)	43
17	Goals conceded (Home / Away)	23
1.51	Goals scored per match average (Competition total)	1.65
2	Goals scored per match average (Home / Away)	1.35
1.4	Conceced goals per match average (Competition total)	1.26
1	Conceced goals per match average (Home / Away)	1.35

Betting aid

20	Number of matches with more than 2,5 goals (Competition total)	21
9	Number of matches with more than 2,5 goals (Home / Away)	8
10	Clean sheets (Competition total)	7
6	Clean sheets (Home / Away)	5
6	Matches without scoring (Competition total)	3
1	Matches without scoring (Home / Away)	2
20	The 2 teams score (Competition total)	24
10	The 2 teams score (Home / Away)	10
2-0 (4 times)	Most frequent score (Home / Away)	1-1 (4 times)

Bookings

52	Yellow cards (Competition total)	74
27	Yellow cards (Home / Away)	40
4	Red cards (Competition total)	2
0	Red cards (Home / Away)	1

Key players

Ola Kamara	18 goals	Team's best scorer (Competition total)	22 goals	David Villa
Ola Kamara	10 goals	Team's best scorer (Home / Away)	7 goals	David Villa
Federico Higuaín	2 penalties	Team's penalty best scorer (Competition total)	4 penalties	David Villa
Federico Higuaín	1 penalty	Team's penalty best scorer (Home / Away)	2 penalties	David Villa
Federico Higuaín	9 assists	Player with most assists (Competition total)	8 assists	Maximiliano Morález
Federico Higuaín	7 assists	Player with most assists (Home / Away)	4 assists	Ben Sweat
Federico Higuaín	7 assists during the last 8 matches	The fittest player	3 goals during the last 3 matches	David Villa

Historical head to head

Home

4 matches

1 v

2 d

1 l

10 gf

10 ga

Away

3 matches

1 v

1 d

1 l

5 gf

7 ga

Total

7 matches

2 v

3 d

2 l

15 gf

17 ga

Historical head to head

Home

3 matches

1 v

1 d

1 l

7 gf

5 ga

Away

4 matches

1 v

2 d

1 l

10 gf

10 ga

Total

7 matches

2 v

3 d

2 l

17 gf

15 ga

Largest victory

Overall	3 - 2	April 16, 2016
Home	3 - 2	April 16, 2016

Largest victory

Overall	4 - 1	October 23, 2016
Away	3 - 2	April 29, 2017

Latest head to head

October 22, 2017 - MLS 2017

New York City FC

2 - 2

Columbus Crew logo Columbus Crew

April 29, 2017 - MLS 2017

Columbus Crew

2 - 3

New York City FC logo New York City FC

October 23, 2016 - MLS 2016

New York City FC

4 - 1

Columbus Crew logo Columbus Crew

August 13, 2016 - MLS 2016

Columbus Crew

3 - 3

New York City FC logo New York City FC

April 16, 2016 - MLS 2016

Columbus Crew

3 - 2

New York City FC logo New York City FC

Best historical scorers against New York City FC

Ethan Finlay	3 goals	2016 - 2016
Ola Kamara	3 goals	2016 - 2017
Justin Meram	3 goals	2015 - 2016
Federico Higuaín	2 goals	2015 - 2017
Kei Kamara	2 goals	2015 - 2016
Josh Williams	1 goal	2017 - 2017

First data collected by footballdatabase.eu on the 19/08/2015. All information before this date, if they exist, might be missing.

Best historical scorers against Columbus Crew

David Villa	7 goals	2016 - 2017
Jack Harrison	3 goals	2016 - 2017
Kwadwo Poku	2 goals	2015 - 2015
Frank Lampard	1 goal	2016 - 2016
Andrew Jacobson	1 goal	2015 - 2015
Stiven Mendoza	1 goal	2016 - 2016

First data collected by footballdatabase.eu on the 19/08/2015. All information before this date, if they exist, might be missing.

Players with most games played vs New York City FC

Federico Higuaín	7 matches	2015 - 2017
Justin Meram	7 matches	2015 - 2017
Will Trapp	7 matches	2015 - 2017
Harrison Afful	7 matches	2015 - 2017
Ethan Finlay	6 matches	2015 - 2017
Michael Parkhurst	5 matches	2015 - 2016

First data collected by footballdatabase.eu on the 19/08/2015. All information before this date, if they exist, might be missing.

Players with most games played vs Columbus Crew

David Villa	6 matches	2015 - 2017
Andoni Iraola	5 matches	2015 - 2016
Jason Hernandez	5 matches	2015 - 2016
Frédéric Brillant	5 matches	2016 - 2017
Andrea Pirlo	5 matches	2015 - 2016
Tommy McNamara	4 matches	2015 - 2016